'Larger than Life' from www.whitworth.manchester.ac.uk |
Although the subject matter is important and has depth, when observing the art I judged and enjoyed it visually; the fact that there was a subject behind it didn't matter to me, though it did make the work feel less playful when seen in context. Now when I see the pieces, instead of folded fabric or old style theatre curtains I see the bottom of a burqa, and the connotations of female oppression and political clashing that accompany it. I think I would have preferred not to know why these pieces were created, perhaps because art is an escape from politics and reality for me; the world is so far from being an acceptable place to live that an unexpected reminder of this makes the situation seem even more bleak.
Interestingly, when I cover the bottom section of this piece, and can only see the pattern with no form, it has none of these connotations and just feels better to look at. This is definately a form of denial, an effort to ignore problems, but if we thought about all the injustice in the world we would never get out of bed in the morning. Much better to keep yourself busy, to loosely quote The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. This is a selfish viewpoint, but a necessary one for me; I design, draw and make things because it makes me happy and I feel productive doing it rather than to broadcast a message to the world. There's enough despair without adding to it, and my cynical side says that people who don't consider world affairs important are unlikely to have a revelation because they see one piece of art.
Having said all of that, I admire Aisha Khalid for being open enough to share her personal experiences and views, and maybe if enough people did that, real change could happen, and my narrower view of what art 'should' be could become ridiculous.